Posted By
Rude One
I'm a very white person. My background is so European, it's painful:
Russian, Polish, Swedish, and, in the only nod to a smidge of color,
Italian. And myfamily history is pure worker: My father was a trucker.
Mom was a secretary. My grandfather was an electrician and my
grandmother worked in a factory. I tell you this to prove my bona fides
when I say, with no due respect, it's time for Democrats and the left to
say, "Fuck the white working class."
That doesn't mean neglect white
workers. As I said back in
November (and repeated in
December), "The
only way to help the white working class is to abandon the white
working class when it comes to trying to get votes." It means that we
concentrate on uplifting all people in this country, no matter the skin
color, and we stop this bullshit outreach to the very white people who
don't understand that it's good for them, too.
It's just pathetic that this keeps coming up again and again, as if
Trump voters and the white working class are the only goddamn prize in
the electorate. Democrats, we're told, and liberals, especially, have
to, got to, must try to get them on board or our victories are hollow
and our policies are meaningless.
Thomas Frank, a progressive darling for his books, including
What's the Matter with Kansas? (the answer he didn't get around to is the obvious one: racism), asked in his
column this weekend for
The Guardian,
"Can liberals please work out how to win back the working class?" It
offers the usual stuff we know, that Democrats should embrace a
genuinely liberal platform, that they blew it by not punishing Wall
Street back in 2009, and that they embrace the wealthy in ways that
alienate the left.
But what's missing is a recognition that the non-white working class is
firmly with the Democratic Party. In fact, it's the base that has
sustained the Democrats for several elections, and if the policies of
the party are accepted by the non-white working class, then you're
either saying that non-whites don't know that Democrats are bad for them
or you're just fucking privileging white workers as being the only
representatives of a class.
Fucking hell, not a single goddamn factory worker voted for Trump
because they were sad Barack Obama didn't lock up someone from Goldman
Sachs. They voted for him because he was gonna chase out the Mexicans
and Muslims and he was gonna teach that Hillary bitch a lesson. It's not
that fucking complicated. And it's fucked up that someone as genuinely
smart as Frank can't just accept that.
Then, today, in the
New York Times (motto: "We will keep
publishing dumb shit until someone from West Virginia subscribes"), in
one of the most tragically stupid columns I've ever fucking seen (and
I've been reading this shit for years), ostensibly liberal writer
Margaret Renkl offers
advice
on "How to Talk to a Racist," subtitled, "White liberals, you’re doing
it all wrong." You might look at that and think, "Oh, c'mon. That's
gotta be a joke."
Nope. Renkl wants us to reason with the unreasonable: "Somehow you need
to find enough common ground for a real conversation about race. Very
few people are stupid or irredeemably mean. They’ll listen to what you
have to say if they trust you’ll listen to what they have to say back."
Look at that shit. It's like she's talking about racists like they're
particularly dumb dogs, not adult humans who could, if they wanted, try
to find common ground with liberals.
It gets worse. You should, she says, stop and take a breath "when you
encounter a person who believes he’s merely honoring his ancestors by
driving a car with an image of the Confederate battle flag on the tag
[or] when a Facebook friend announces that it’s disrespectful to take a
knee during the national anthem." I'll take a breath if the exhale is me
saying, "Racist asshole."
I've said this before and I'll say it again: Why is it just up to
liberals? Unlike writers like Renkl, I'm not gonna act like racists are
children. I'm gonna treat them like fuckin' grown-ups and not fuckin'
patronize them and speak gently so they don't roll on the ground in a
tantrum. I'm gonna tell 'em they're fuckin' racist and that racism is
objectively wrong and they should be ashamed of their ignorant selves.
And if they don't like being made to feel bad for being racist, don't
fucking be racist. Now, tell me whatever stupid shit you wanna say about
how you have black friends.
Democrats and the left need to get over this obsession with making the
white working class happy. Reaching out to them only makes them hate us
more. Why do we need them all? There is already a good percentage of
them that do vote Democratic because they're also not all racist morons.
Those white working class members are pretty sick of the idiots in
their demographic, too.
Besides, it ain't like the white working class has a monopoly on rage or
morality. Holy Republicans may hammer the Bible like it's their
mistress's ass, but your evangelicals haven't got shit on the black
church or the enormous growth of Hispanics as part of church
congregations. Go get your voters there.
And the rise of women candidates, both non-white and white, as well as
LGBT candidates, demonstrates that the future sure as hell ain't the
white men that still make up the vast majority of Republican elected
officials. The awesome thing about these new candidates is they are
coming up with ways to present that liberal, pro-worker agenda as
something that is simply common sense. That goes across the board, from
Beto O'Rourke in Texas, a white Congressman who is uniting
constituencies (mostly not white) in a real shot to take down Ted Cruz,
to Jeannine Lee Lake in Indiana, a black woman who won the Democratic
nomination in a district that once had Mike Pence representing it. The
DNC and the DCCC
better get the fuck on board or the party is gonna leave their old asses behind.
Just think: non-white Americans, with an assist from some white
Americans, could end up being responsible for changing things to
actually make shit better for the white working class. That many of them
won't understand it, as they didn't when Barack Obama was getting them
health care, is the triumph of the GOP politics of hate and fear and
ignorance.
[Note: Yes, in very white places like West Virginia, where Democrats
still have a chance, you might have to pander a bit, but the basic
message doesn't need to change.]